International Journal of Psychotherapy Practice and Research
ISSN: 2574-612X
Current Issue
Volume No: 1 Issue No: 3
share this page

Research Article | Open Access
  • Available online freely | Peer Reviewed
  • Consequences of Repression of Emotion: Physical Health, Mental Health and General Well Being

    Jainish Patel 1     Prittesh Patel 2      

    1Indira Gandhi National Open University, Regional Center, Surat

    2C. G. Bhakta Institute of Biotechnology, Uka Tarsadia University, Bardoli

    Abstract

    The widely held belief that emotional and psychological processes affect our physical health, mental health and general well-being are central to a holistic view of the individual, and as such, it is a useful foundational concept in integrative medicine. The purpose of this paper is to review substantial amounts of the latest research and recent findings on this issue to enable us to throw some light on how inhibitory factors to emotional expression and experience can endanger our health, both physically and psychologically including our general wellbeing. In addition, the connection between repression of emotion and certain mental disorders like depression and scientifically proven healthy ways to manage issues bordering on emotion was outlined. The information contained in this paper is just as important to health care providers and also to the patients they deal with

    Received 22 Dec 2018; Accepted 09 Feb 2019; Published 12 Feb 2019;

    Academic Editor:Wei Xu, School of Psychology, Nanjing Normal University, China.

    Checked for plagiarism: Yes

    Review by: Single-blind

    Copyright©  2019 Jainish Patel, et al.

    License
    Creative Commons License    This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

    Competing interests

    The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

    Citation:

    Jainish Patel, Prittesh Patel (2019) Consequences of Repression of Emotion: Physical Health, Mental Health and General Well Being. International Journal of Psychotherapy Practice and Research - 1(3):16-21.
    Download as RIS, BibTeX, Text (Include abstract )
    DOI10.14302/issn.2574-612X.ijpr-18-2564

    Introduction

    In psychology, repression of emotion is an aspect of emotion regulation. It is a concept that is based on individual’s knowledge of emotions, which includes causes of emotion, sensations of the body and about behavior that are expressed, and their possible means of modification 1. Repression of emotion implies the act of masking facial and bodily expressions in order to conceal a current emotional status. Repression of emotion can also be defined as the intentional and automatic method by which individuals exert control over the emotions they have, altering factors like when and how the emotions are experienced and expressed 2. Effective regulation of emotion enables the individual to adaptively cope with a broad range of environmental eventualities. However, when it goes uneven or lopsided, it becomes increasingly recognized and its negative consequences may pose danger to emotional and cognitive health. It may thus become a potential development or maintenance factor in mental or physical disease conditions 3, 4, 5. Toxic affect is talking about the novel idea that negative emotional conditions can have consequences for the physical health of an individual. Reviews from available research indicate that both anxiety disorders and depressive symptoms are implicated as risk factors for people with cardiac abnormalities 6.

    It becomes important to understand the positive and negative consequences of different emotion regulation strategies. In this respect, controversy is ongoing in the field about the repercussions of deliberate attempts to repress emotion, defined here as intentional attempts to down-regulate the inward experience and outward expression of undesired effect. Contradictory predictions arise from normative and clinical works of literature concerning the consequences of such repression of emotion.

    Clinical and Normative Findings

    People repeatedly and rapidly forget and re-discover that emotional status has a direct and profound influence on physical and mental health 7. Freud discovered links between repression of emotion and physical symptoms nearly a century ago. Wolff and his colleagues also documented fixed physiological responses to emotional activation in more than three decades worth of research 8. More recently, research findings have been adding up in support of the notion that the relationship between emotional and physical health is direct and reciprocal. Research has shown that over 80% of all physicians’ visits have to do with a socio-emotional challenge, while just only 16% could be considered solely pathophysiologic in nature. One study discovered that 84 % of 567 common complaints, such as dizziness and chest pain, indicated no medical diagnosis 9. A recent study out of the UK discovered that about 25% of all new specialty referrals and about 20% of all referrals requiring surgery resulted in no particular medical diagnoses 10. It becomes imperative and clear that a more keen understanding of the roles of emotions in the occurrence and progression of symptomatic suffering is necessary in order to curtail the staggering amount of medical costs spent involved in diagnosing these symptoms that are borne out of emotional imbalance. Abbass (2002) further made this very clear by documenting the enormous cost savings to the system when such cases are given brief emotionally focused psychotherapy 11. Learning and understanding how and when such therapies come into the treatment plan of medical systems will be a great service to all and sundry.

    Management of Emotions

    The ways in which humans manage their emotions has become one of the most important but least examined concerns in medicine today. Emotions are physiological phenomena 12. When poorly managed or regulated, they can lead to negative health and psychological consequences 13.

    One important factor that links emotions and health disorders has to do with the (dys) regulation of emotions 14. Patients with difficulties in managing their emotions subject their health and wellbeing into gross negligence and as a result are more likely to display a history of substance abuse, poor nutrition, and disordered eating, lack of exercise, abnormal sleep patterns, poor compliance with medical interventions and behaviors that are injurious to one self. These patients make use of medical services like emergency rooms and medications, at tremendous rates. Because they often fail to stick to the directives of medical advice and treatment prescriptions, such patient s create conflicts with health workers and are more likely to file complaints in the court than patients that are emotionally healthy and stable 15.

    It is important to acknowledge that feelings and emotions are not responsible for health disorders and sicknesses. Rather it is the protracted reliance on self-defense against the expression of emotions and feelings that creates the tension required for the disease to thrive 16. Conversely, the free and uninterrupted expression of emotion possesses clear and sustainable benefits for physical and mental health and general wellbeing. In fact, research on aging and longevity has demonstrated that psychological factors bordering on emotions are more important predictors of a long, healthy life than other factors like diet and activeness 17. Individuals who remain actively involved in issues of life has a sense of hope and sheer optimism and can deal with moments of sadness by finding purpose and meaning, instead of bowing to depressed and despondency. They are also more likely to live longer and healthier than their pessimistic counterparts.

    Physiological Consequences of Repression

    Studies by Pennebaker and his colleagues (1997) demonstrated that individuals who repress their emotions also suppress their body’s immunity, making them more vulnerable to a variety of illnesses ranging from common colds to cancer 5. Again, individuals who mask and deny their inward feelings, or outwardly vent their emotions, characteristically suffer most. “Studies of patients with serious medical conditions such as cancer, diabetes, kidney failure, and obesity, reveals that those who do not comply with medical advice also show strong use of defense mechanisms” 5. Other findings have demonstrated that patient with cancer and other forms of malignancy that chronically mask their experiences and feelings are more liable to die despite treatments than expressive patients 18, 19. Empirical evidence indicates a substantial reduction in pain and discomfort from arthritis following the expression of negative. As a matter of fact, the amount of relief from pain and discomfort reported by patients with chronic illness has been found to be commensurate with how able they are too deeply and authentically express their emotions and feelings. The Table 1 shows some of the physiological manifestations repression of emotion health workers are likely to come across.

    Table 1. Emotionally linked complaints and disorders (Abbass, 2005)
    Specialty Complaint/Disorder
    Cardiology Hypertension, Chest Pain, Palpitations
    Dermatology Psoriasis, Dermatitis, Itching
    Endocrinology Fatigue, Obesity, Thyroid Dysfunction
    Gastroenterology Irritable Bowel Syndrome, Dyspepsia, Abdominal Pain
    Internal Medicine Weakness, Pain, Fatigue
    Neurology Conversion, Paralysis, Headache, Dizziness, Pseudo-Seizures
    Gynecology Pelvic Pain, Sexual Dysfunction, Infertility
    Ophthalmology Visual Blurring, Tunnel Vision, Blindness
    Respirology Shortness Of Breath, Choking Spells, Chest Pain
    Rheumatology Fibromyalgia, Fatigue, Chronic Pain
    Surgery Back Pain, Neck Pain, Abdominal Pain
    Urology Urethral Syndrome, Sexual Dysfunction

    Psychological Consequences of Repression

    Repression of emotion is one of the most common strategies of regulating emotion used by humans. Clinical traditions made it clear that the psychological health of an individual depends on how effective impulses are managed or regulated; the consequences of effective regulation and management are, therefore, the main focus of researchers in clinical psychology. Gross & Levenson (1993) explained how the psychological consequences directly related to repression of emotion are subjects of frequent dispute among researchers 4. Researchers such as Cannon (1927) and Jones (1935) are of the opinion that suppressing a physical emotional response while emotionally prompted to express will increase the intensity of the emotional experience as a result of the concentration on suppressing the emotion 20, 21. These researchers debate that common sense makes us understand that emotions become increasingly severe or intense the longer they are bottled up. Some other researchers such as Darwin (1872) and Tomkins (1984) express their disagreement with this theory with the view that emotional expression is crucial to the overall emotional response and that when there is repression, all other contingent responses (e.g. physiological) are weakened 22, 23. Darwin (1872) and Tomkins (1984) threw more light on this argument by stating the obvious that people are taught to count numbers to ten when emotionally distressed in order to calm down 22, 23. If repression of emotions were to increase the intensity of the expressible emotional experience, this counting tradition would only increase the response of the person emotionally aroused; however, the reverse is actually the case 22, 23. Unfortunately, few pieces of research have been conducted to test these hypotheses 24. The fact that people have contrasting opinions on which is the idea- to repress emotion by counting numerals to ten to calm down before acting or expressing the way you feel because repressing your emotions is injurious to your mental health is of increasing interest and concerns to experts in the psychology of emotions.

    The Connection with Stress

    The various physiological, cognitive, and motivational, and physiological attributes of emotions may shed some light on their relation with hypertension as one of the risk factors of cardiac malfunction. Previous studies has indicated that stress is linked with increased cortisol levels, This has gained support from other research findings showing that how the body responds during stress depend on how one is able to deal with the stress 25. Concealing and repressing emotions can give rise to stress-related physiological reactions. The occurrence of stress is as a result of the social disapproval and punishment of overt emotional expression that cause repression which is itself intimidating and stressful 26. There are certain fields of human endeavor which require the repression of positive or negative emotions such as: estate agents who may hide their happiness when a good offer is tabled on house sake of maintaining their professionalism, or primary school teachers suppressing their anger or disappointment sake of upsetting their young pupils when teaching them good morals.

    Recently, researchers have started to look into the effects which continual repression of emotion in the workplace may have on people 27. Cote (2005) stated that continual repression brings about stress on individuals making use of it 27. Stress brought about by such protracted repression of emotion can cause an increase in heart rate, anxiety, low level of commitment and other effects which can be detrimental to the productivity of an employee. The popular belief is that repression of emotion in the workplace is advantageous for the organization and dangerous for the employee on a long-term basis. However, Cote (2005) discovered that factors giving rise to the social dynamics of emotions determine whether regulation of emotion affects stress or not 27. The repression of unpleasant emotions such as anger gives rise to elevated levels of stress.

    Repression and Depression: The Link

    Repression of emotion, as a strategy to regulate emotions, is useful in certain aspects of life such as supporting ambitions pursuits and bringing satisfaction to hedonic needs 28. In as much as repression of emotion is regarded as a weak influence on emotional experience, it plays other useful roles. Repression of emotion is a goal-oriented strategy which is guided by people’s beliefs and customs and potentially by abstract ideas about the regulation of emotion 28. In a research conducted by Larsen et al. (2012) the researchers investigated the possibility of a positive association between repression of emotion and symptoms of depression in adults and adolescents under the influence of peer victimization and parental support 28. A reciprocal relationship was discovered to exist between parental support and symptoms of depression but there was no symptom of depression with peer victimization. Depressive symptoms were discovered in the subjects following decreased perception of parental support after a year.

    Recommendations and Conclusion

    In conclusion, it is clear that expressing one’s true emotions and the feeling is crucial to physical health, mental health, and general well being, while a reliance on concealment gives rise to a barrier to good health. In as much as having a family member or a trusted friend to confide in seems like the best option, it is not the only one. Talking with a psychotherapist or a counselor is another method of getting help. Alternatively, one may resort to writing down ones true feelings and emotions, or simply recording with tape the particular events in one's life that have been most upsetting and emotionally distressing. These practices have been found to have beneficial effects in managing and regulating emotions. Facing what one has been trying to avoid can elevate one's sense of distress or emotional arousal in the short term, the benefits are far much greater as one gains emotional stability, physical and mental health, and also a wider understanding of oneself and others. Most importantly, the long-term benefits are only for people who are willing to get involved in this process emotionally. Having someone to talk to about your feelings in a state of detachment will not help one achieve much in becoming emotionally stable, talking to an expert will do more.

    References

    1.P M Niedenthal, Krauth-Gruber S, Ric F. (2006) Psychology of emotion: Interpersonal, experimental and cognitive approaches. , New York: 432.
    2.Gross J. (1989) Emotional expression in cancer onset and progression. , Social Science & Medicine 28, 1239-1248.
    3.Berenbaum H, Raghavan C, H N Le, L, J. (2003) A taxonomy of emotional disturbances. , Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 10, 206-226.
    4.J, R W Levenson. (1997) Hiding feelings: the acute effects of inhibiting negative and positive emotion. , Journal of abnormal psychology 106, 95.
    5.J W Pennebaker. (1997) Opening up: The healing power of expressing emotions. , Guilford
    6.Suls J, Bunde J. (2005) Anger, anxiety, and depression as risk factors for cardiovascular disease: the problems and implications of overlapping affective dispositions. Psychological bulletin 131. 260.
    7.Coughlin Della Selva, P. (2006) Emotional processing in the treatment of psychosomatic disorders. , Journal of clinical 62-539.
    8.H G Wolff. (1968) . Stress and disease, (Thomas)
    9.Kroenke K, A D Mangelsdorff. (1989) Common symptoms in ambulatory care: incidence, evaluation, therapy, and outcome. The American journal of medicine86. 262-266.
    10.Reid S, Wessely S, Crayford T, Hotopf M. (2001) Medically unexplained symptoms in frequent attenders of secondary health care: retrospective cohort study. , Bmj 322, 767.
    11.A. (2003) The cost-effectiveness of short-term dynamic psychotherapy. , Expert review of pharmacoeconomics & outcomes research 3, 535-539.
    12.Antonio D. (1999) The feeling of what happens: Body and emotion in the making of consciousness. , New York:
    13.Abbass A. (2005) The case for specialty-specific core curriculum on emotions and health. , Royal Coll Outlook 4, 5-7.
    14.Appleton A, Kubzansky L. (2014) Emotion regulation and cardiovascular disease risk. Handbook of emotion regulation. 2, 596-612.
    15.R I Lanyon, E R Almer. (2002) Characteristics of compensable disability patients who choose to litigate. , Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law Online 30, 400-404.
    16.Cramer P. (2000) Defense mechanisms in psychology today: Further processes for adaptation. , American Psychologist 55, 637.
    17.D, D A Snowdon, W V Friesen. (2001) Positive emotions in early life and longevity: findings from the nun study. , Journal of personality and social psychology 80, 804.
    18.L R Derogatis, Abeloff, Melisaratos N. (1979) Psychological coping mechanisms and survival time in metastatic breast cancer. , Jama 242, 1504-1508.
    19.D A Goldstein, M H Antoni. (1989) The distribution of repressive coping styles among non-metastatic and metastatic breast cancer patients as compared to non-cancer patients. , Psychology and Health 3, 245-258.
    20.W B Cannon. (1927) The James-Lange theory of emotions: A critical examination and an alternative theory. , The American journal of psychology 39, 106-124.
    21.H E Jones. (1935) The galvanic skin reflex as related to overt emotional expression. , The American Journal of Psychology 47, 241-251.
    22.Darwin Recognition, C. (1872) . The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals. M] , London: .
    23.Ekman P. (1984) Expression and the nature of emotion. , Hillsdale, N] Erlbaum 319-344.
    24.J, R W Levenson. (1993) Emotional suppression: physiology, self-report, and expressive behavior. , Journal of personality and social psychology 64, 970.
    25.J P, E J Hangen, H Y Lee, D S Yeager. (2018) Capitalizing on appraisal processes to improve affective responses to social stress. , Emotion Review 10, 30-39.
    26.Buck R. (2003) Emotional expression, suppression, and control: Nonverbal communication in cultural context. , Journal of Intercultural Communication Research 32, 175-187.
    27.Cote S. (2005) A social interaction model of the effects of emotion regulation on work strain. , Academy of management review 30, 509-530.
    28.J K Larsen, A, Eisinga R, English T, J et al. (2012) Social coping by masking? Parental support and peer victimization as mediators of the relationship between depressive symptoms and expressive suppression in adolescents. , Journal of Youth and Adolescence 41, 1628-1642.