Complaints and Appeals Policy

How to raise a concern about any Open Access Pub journal, who handles it, and how authors can appeal an editorial decision.

1. Scope

This policy applies to all journals published by Open Access Pub. It covers complaints about the handling of a manuscript or the conduct of peer review, concerns about publication ethics (for example suspected plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, authorship disputes, undisclosed conflicts of interest or redundant publication), concerns about published content, and complaints about publisher services. It also sets out how authors can appeal an editorial decision on their manuscript.

Anyone may raise a concern: authors, reviewers, editors, readers or third parties. Concerns are handled confidentially and fairly, and raising a concern in good faith has no effect on how any future submission from the same person is assessed. Whether an article processing charge has been or will be paid has no bearing on how a complaint or appeal is handled.

2. How to make a complaint

Please write to the editorial office at [email protected] or use the form on our Contact us page. To help us act on the complaint, please include:

  • the journal name and, where relevant, the manuscript number or the article title and DOI;
  • a clear description of the concern and the outcome you are seeking;
  • any supporting evidence, such as documents, correspondence or links.

Concerns about research or publication misconduct are considered when they are raised anonymously, provided they are supported by specific information and evidence that can be checked.

3. Who handles a complaint

  • The editorial office acknowledges each complaint, normally within 2 working days, records it and coordinates the response.
  • Matters that involve editorial judgement are referred to the Editor-in-Chief of the journal concerned (or, where a journal has no Editor-in-Chief in post, to a designated senior editor of that journal). Complaints about the Editor-in-Chief are handled by the publisher.
  • No one named in a complaint, or with a conflict of interest in it, takes part in assessing it.
  • Cases that cannot be resolved at journal level, and all cases of suspected misconduct, are handled following the guidance and flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Where appropriate, we may seek independent expert advice or contact the authors' institution.

4. What happens next

We aim to send a reasoned response within 30 days of acknowledging a complaint. Some cases, particularly those that require information from authors, reviewers or institutions, take longer; in that case we keep the person who raised the concern informed of progress. Where a complaint concerns a published article, the outcome may be a correction, an expression of concern or a retraction, as described in our Retraction Policy.

5. Appeals against editorial decisions

  • Authors may appeal a decision on their manuscript within 30 days of the decision by writing to [email protected], quoting the manuscript number.
  • An appeal should explain why the decision should be reconsidered, respond point by point to the reviewer and editor comments, and include any new data or evidence that bears on the decision.
  • The appeal is assessed by an editor who was not involved in the original decision. That editor may consult the Editor-in-Chief and, where needed, an additional independent reviewer.
  • The possible outcomes are: the original decision is upheld; the manuscript is sent for further review; or the decision is revised. The author receives a reasoned response.
  • An appeal is not a second round of peer review and does not guarantee a change of decision. Only one appeal is considered per manuscript, and the decision on the appeal is final.
  • Please do not submit the manuscript to another journal while an appeal is under consideration.

See also our Publication Ethics page, the AI Use Policy and the Retraction Policy. Where a journal's own pages give additional, journal-specific instructions, those apply as well.